Trying Pickle for the first time? Your first rental is covered by our Risk-Free Fit Guarantee. If your item doesn’t fit, we’ll give you a full refund in Pickle Credits, no matter what the owner’s normal fit-refund settings are.
To be eligible, you must:
Report the fit issue within 12 hours of receiving the item, and
Schedule a same-day return through the Pickle app
Once the item is returned, Pickle will issue the refund in credits directly — the owner does not lose earnings on your first rental.
This policy applies only to your first-ever rental on Pickle. All future fit refunds follow the owner’s chosen fit-refund settings.